Animal Soul


Human souls are imagined by humans to give us comfort about the fact of death. Animal souls are imagined by humans for the same reason. As far as we know, animals do not practice religion, although it is possible some are capable of the abstract thought necessary to imagine an afterlife and wrestle with their own impending non-existence.

This is most likely not common, but there are some species that really do have incredible capacity for intelligence. Frankly, contemplating whether animals have souls seems a bit beside the point. The more relevant question is “How badly are we allowed to treat animals without guilt?”

Which is ultimately a personal decision based on the dictates of our own conscience. It is, however, a personal decision with global ramifications. Human economics is the single largest threat to natural resources. When beaver hides or elephant tusks or passenger pigeon meat becomes a commodity, those species are driven to or beyond the edge of extinction. When we stop appreciating a forest for what it is and instead see it as potential farmland, the habitat of thousands of species begins vanish overnight. Even with species we have bred to eat, when we stop seeing them as living beings and simply see them as little meat machines, we accept factory farm conditions that would have been unthinkable even to the livestock farmers of 200 years ago.

Even if we decide that individually animals have no rights and that a human should be allowed to treat an animal however they wish, when the aggregate effect of these choices made for economic reasons begins to threaten the very existence of a species, surely we must pause and weigh the cost. Do we want to live in a world with no lions or polar bears or eagles? Would it even be possible for to humans to survive a world with no rain forests to keep the air fresh or ice caps to maintain sea level?

These are not hypothetical questions. These are very real conversations being had around the world right now. As living things, humans have a connection to all other living things. We may have reached the top of the food chain, but if the chain is broken, we too will perish.

As the earth’s most powerful species, we have a responsibility to be good stewards. This means there will always be a tug and pull between economic and environmental interests which will play out at all levels, from political to personal. A perfect example of this is whether or not one should eat meat. It takes thousands of calories of plant matter and gallons of water and tanks of gasoline to get a steak to your plate.

Every time you choose meat instead of vegetables, you are choosing to use exponentially more resources for the same number of calories. So again, whether or not there is a moral imperative to treat animals a certain way, we should be aware of the costs. We have become so separate from nature. It would not be a bad thing if, as a prerequisite to being allowed to eat meat, a person had to visit a slaughterhouse or butcher their own food at least once.



15 thoughts on “Animal Soul

    1. Really? If you care even a little bit about climate change, animal abuse, world hunger, deforestation, human health, the oceans, you really really really need to take a long hard look at what you eat. As much as people don’t want to admit it, animal agriculture is killing the environment, animals, and humans, and the longer society refuses to admit it the more damage is going to be done. I am not asking you to become overly sensitive tree-hugging animal lovers

      I just want you to realize that the reaction you would have at someone beating a cow because they liked how it felt should be the same reaction as someone killing and eating a cow because they liked how it tasted.

      This isn’t some crazy hippy shit. It is applying logic and reasoning to our ethics when it comes to how we treat other sentient beings on this planet.:D
      Check this link:

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Oh,I know the science. However, I am talking of balance. The way that agricultural productivity is pushed up, and pesticides are put into crops, being a vegetarian is not that green either…
        Balance is key

        Liked by 1 person

  1. A chapter from you in environment science book won’t be bad at all. 😉
    But just for a thought, I feel like we are losing the plot in keeping the environment balanced. Global warming is the biggest concern and it is hitting hard. Watched the documentry out from ‘Vice’ and it has a reality to tell.


  2. Dear AR,
    There is one thing we know about most “HIGHER” forms of life, though we don’t often think about it, life feeds on life, and it does not matter if that life is plant or animal. I am not about to debate the cost to life whether we are eating meat or plant material, eating costs an exorbitant amount of life, and we should be searching for something that does not cost life to sustain life. But is this even possible?
    In the above post you obviously believe that animals (Does that include insects, shellfish, bacteria, and viruses?) are living beings, but I cannot sense whether you see plants as living beings. I see anything that comes into being, whether from seeds, spores, eggs, or mytosis, then grows and changes, and eventually dies, as a living being. I do not draw lines between them. And I further believe that all living beings have spirits (which I differentiate from the religious word “souls”). (Spirits continue to exist after death, but have nothing to do with gods,
    and everything to do with life.) Be that as it may, my own belief system, I do grant you that meat, especially that from land-based animals, takes a lot more energy to produce than does most plant material, but it also provides protein in much higher concentrations than protein from plants. So, whether you eat plant material, or meat, you are still killing something, sometimes millions of something. Which cost is greater? I have no way to judge…


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s